• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Ultimate Roofing Material Comparison

Ultimate Roofing Material Comparison

Popular Types of Kitchen Backsplashes

When it comes to roofing and materials, there are a lot of choices available on the market. It can be difficult to determine which material is the best for your home, and even more difficult to find a reliable contractor who can install it for you.

This guide will help you understand the different types of roofing materials available, as well as some factors you should consider when choosing one. We will also provide tips on how to find a reputable roofing contractor who will install your roof correctly and within your budget and needs. So, if you're ready to learn more about roofing materials and their associated costs, let's get started!

If you want to ensure the performance and durability of your rooftop, two critical elements are essential: superior material quality and experienced roofing contractors. When both of these factors come together, you can rest assured that your rooftop will be in top-notch condition for years to come.

1. Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most common material used for residential and commercial rooftops due to their affordability, durability, and wide array of stylish colors.

  • Their versatility lies in their ability to accommodate a wide range of shapes and angles.
  • These durable shingles are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions, providing superior protection against fire and high winds.
  • Although their lifespan may not be as long as that of metal, with proper care and maintenance you can expect to get around 20 years out of them.
  • Cost-effective repairs are easy to come by and individual shingles can be replaced with ease, making it a breeze to restore any missing or damaged pieces.
  • Homeowners who are on a tight budget can take comfort in knowing that this is the most cost-efficient choice for roofing.

2. Metal Roofs

Metal roofs provide the perfect solution for modern homes and farmhouses, as they are incredibly durable, energy-efficient, and can be properly maintained. Not only will a metal roof stand up to high winds, hail, or any other rough weather conditions that may come its way, but it also guarantees you an extended lifetime of protection. If you're considering if a metal roof would be the perfect selection for your house, then take into account these thrilling advantages.

  • Metal roofing such as standing seam metal roofs have the potential to outlast traditional shingle options, which means that a higher initial investment can pay off over time. These roofs have an average lifespan of 50 years and up to 70 with proper care - definitely worth considering when it comes to protecting your home or business.
  • Labeled "Eco-friendly," there are numerous explanations why this roofing material fits the criteria. However, its capacity to be wholly recycled at the end of its useful life is one noteworthy justification for such characterization.
  • Metal roofing provides unparalleled fire resistance, making your home secure and safe. It also reflects heat extremely well, mitigating the effects of direct sunlight on utility bills in the summertime. By positioning metal roofing over resistant material, you can rest assured that your family is sheltered from potential danger - all while saving money!
  • Metal roofs are engineered to maximally shed snow and rain, drastically lowering the probability of structural damage caused by these harsh weather conditions. Moreover, this type of roofing prevents any kind of accumulation that could otherwise result in a collapsed roof.

3. Tile Roofs

You can't mistake the look of the tile roofing system. In fact, its unique look is one of the reasons homeowners make the decision to opt for this type of roofing material just like slate roof. Tile roofing is among the most in-demand when it comes to enhancing visual appeal. Although you need to make a higher initial investment, its benefits are worth every penny! Tile roofs have one of the maximum lifespans out there and they offer plenty more advantages.

  • When it comes to longevity, tile is an unsurpassed choice. Even metal roofing - which is known for its long-lasting quality – barely stands a chance next to the century of durability that tile offers. While metal roofs such as standing seam metal roof tend to last about 50 years on average, the lifespan of a properly installed and maintained tile roof can stretch up to 100 years!
  • Investing in tile roofing will give you the assurance that your roof is protected from rot and insect damage, two common issues with roofs. You can take comfort in knowing that your money has gone towards a material that won't wear away over time.
  • Investing in tile roofing can provide you with the low-maintenance option that you're looking for. With a minimal chance of leaking and almost no maintenance required, tiles are certainly the way to go. And contrary to popular belief, they'll never break that easily - if a heavy impact does lead to them being damaged, it's highly convenient as all you have to do is replace individual tiles.

Needing a High Quality Contractor To Nail Your Next Project?

We Have Decades of Combined Experience Building Hundreds of Roofs in East Tennessee. Give us a call to find out why we are the choice for so many home owners!

4. Flat Roofing

Flat roofing systems are becoming increasingly popular in both residential and commercial buildings, and for a variety of excellent reasons. Flat roofs provide one of the most efficient ways to secure your structure; they make ideal storage areas or an outdoor garden oasis, plus you can easily access them for maintenance checks.

  • With a flat roof in place, the opportunities for storage are endless. Installation of air conditioners or even rooftop gardens and solar panels is an available alternative that you can select to enhance your home's exterior look. The decision on how to best utilize this newly accessible space is yours!
  • Accessing your storage or garden on your roof will be much easier. This type of roof is easy to access for maintenance services such as gutter cleaning and roof repairs – making them the ideal choice for such tasks.
  • Not only does a flat roof impact the exterior of your home or business, but it also alters how you are able to use the interior as well. This eliminates any problematic sloped roofs that render using the space.

5. Wood Shingle or Shake Roofing

A wooden shake roof offers a classic and rustic aesthetic that many homeowners prefer. Such roofs are often seen on homes with country-style architecture, giving it added charm. Unfortunately, these roofs come with significant maintenance requirements so if you're looking for an easy-to-manage option then this might not be the best choice for you. However, if aesthetics is your prime concern then wood shakes will satisfy your needs while also adding value to your home.

  • When it comes to wood roofing, you're presented with two distinct options: shakes or shingles. Shingles are cut by machine and have different variations of cuts that can be along the grain or against it. In contrast, shakes are split manually so one side is always parallel to the grain.
  • Wood is a remarkable insulator, meaning it will keep your home comfortably insulated in the winter and cool during the summer months. Additionally, wood shakes are incredibly resilient against wind damage - cedar and redwood especially can increase the sturdiness of an entire roof deck when put into place! All in all, wooden shingles provide superior insulation as well as protection from extreme weather elements.
  • Wood may have lots of advantages, yet its high-maintenance requirements can make it an expensive choice. You are able to protect it from rot and algae with protective treatments and coatings, however, this will require regular applications. Additionally, wood is flammable making it inadvisable for homes situated near wildfire-prone areas.

6. Synthetic Materials (such as TPO & EPDM)

For commercial facilities, TPO and EPDM single-ply membrane roofs provide a protective layer. These roofing options consist of sheets of rubber or other synthetics that are either ballasted to the insulation or chemically adhered in place.

Perfect for commercial, industrial, and multi-family dwellings, these roofing materials are the optimal selection when it comes to nearly flat roofs. With its elasticity, resilience and slippery nature this type of system can successfully withstand even the most intense weather conditions such as rain or snow.

  • EPDM is a highly durable roofing material that can easily last more than two decades. Coupled with polyiso insulation, it has remarkable thermal efficiency, particularly when purchased in white. TPO stands out from other materials due to its extraordinary resistance to ozone, ultraviolet rays, and some chemicals at an affordable rate. Additionally, it wards off mold growth and repels dirt accumulation as well as tear impacts and punctures which makes it one of the most reliable options available today.
  • As for full observation of EPDM and TPO's real durability, newer technology makes for a lack of a proven track record.
  • Re-roofing job calls for the complete removal of your existing roof. Though it is laborious and comes with additional estimated cost per square foot, this must be done to ensure an effective replacement of your new roof especially if you opt for these synthetic and modern roofing materials.

Each of the six roofing types we've covered has its own unique benefits and drawbacks. Keep in mind that what might be the perfect roof for one person may not be ideal for another. So, take some time to consider your specific needs and wants before making a decision - you can't go wrong with any of these six popular roofing materials.

Whether you choose asphalt shingles, wood shakes, or synthetic materials like TPO and EPDM, make sure you consider all the pros and cons carefully in order to make the best choice for your home or business.

Knoxville, TN, North and South Carolina Premiere Contractor

If you have already decided on the type of roofing and materials you want your roof to have, the next crucial step to consider is the contractor that will do the roofing job for you.

No matter how good the quality your roofing materials boast, with the wrong handiwork and improper installation of the wrong roofing contractor, they are bound to produce costly disasters to your pocket and home. So it is vital to look for an experienced and reliable contractor.

For years, Green Home Installations has been the trusted name in residential roofing across Tennessee. Our crew is highly experienced and skilled at installing roofs of all types; we even take extra precautions to ensure that our work meets the highest quality standards by thoroughly inspecting each job before completion! We are fully licensed and insured for your protection, so you can trust us with your next roof installation project. Recently, we have extended our services to North and South Carolina due to the high demand for our services.

Our team of highly-acclaimed experts specializes in the installation of a wide range of roofing systems, such as asphalt shingles, metal, and TPO/EPDM. Our dedication to excellence has earned us recognition from numerous reputable organizations - including the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Angie's List, and OSHA - which ensures that our customers can trust our services with unwavering confidence. We consistently strive for maximum customer satisfaction by providing top-quality workmanship on every project we take on!

If you happen to be in the Knoxville area or North and South Carolina, give us a call for a free roof inspection and quote!

And even we have not mentioned some of the other roofing materials and systems such as overlapping layers of slate roofs, slate shingles, wood shingles, composite shingles, clay tile, and natural wood, we have other roofing guides that will surely help you.

Helpful Roofing Articles


Reach Out to Our Friendly Staff To Discuss Your Project


215 Center Park Dr #1800, Knoxville, TN, 37922

Contact Info:

(865) 409-2478


0 of 350